PHAI Argues for Brookline Tobacco Ban at SJC
The Massachusetts town of Brookline is not just blowing smoke when it comes to ending the tobacco epidemic. As of September 1, 2021, no one born in the 21st century is allowed to buy tobacco in the Boston suburb of 60,000 people after town meeting voters adopted a first-in-the-nation bylaw prohibiting tobacco or e-cigarette sales to anyone born on or after January 1, 2000. While support for the new regulation is strong, a challenge brought by a group of Brookline tobacco merchants was recently argued before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC).
Brookline is represented by Northeastern Law’s Public Health Advocacy Institute (PHAI), which argues that the ban is legal under a 2018 state law allowing towns or cities to pursue their own rule that “limits or prohibits the purchase of tobacco products.” Governor Maura Healey ’98 approved the Brookline bylaw when she served as the commonwealth’s attorney general.
“Brookline is the first place in the world to implement this type of policy, and believe it or not, there are many advocates around the globe following this case,” said Mark Gottlieb ’93, executive director of PHAI.
During oral arguments before the SJC in November, those opposed to the regulation argued that it could have wide ramifications for convenience stores, where tobacco products account for more than one-quarter of merchandise sales nationally, according to a Massachusetts trade group representing local retailers. The high court will decide whether to uphold a lower court’s decision to dismiss the lawsuit, known as Six Brothers v. Brookline, where store owners argued Brookline’s tobacco ban undercuts the 2018 law and the intent of the legislature to set a minimum sales age for tobacco at 21.
“Brookline’s approach is to eventually eliminate tobacco sales in the town, but the real public health impact will be felt when other communities join this effort, which requires a favorable outcome in the litigation,” said Gottlieb.
Share
Over the past year, Professor Kara Swanson, a leading authority on the intersections of intellectual property with race, gender and sexuality and on the history of science and technology, has reveled in the intellectual joy of fellowships from Kansas City to the land of the Kiwis.
The 2024 Brown Forum for Women in the Law Conference focused on women, media and the law with an eye to upcoming elections, on every level, and with a lens on issues that are critical to women’s health.
Professor Hilary Robinson and colleagues from Northeastern University’s College of Engineering and College of Social Sciences and Humanities and Boston College are wrapping up a collaborative project, Understanding the Algorithmic Workplace: A Multi-Method Study for Comprehensive Optimization of Platforms, funded by a three-year, $1.5 million grant from the National Science Foundation.
